Shore Things

« Mr. Postman, Look and See..... | MAIN | Gardenia Needs Some Whitening Strips »

Posted by Steve Bender, May 15, 2009 in Trees and Shrubs

Sometimes in order to get people to do something good, you have to make them understand what's bad. With that thought in mind, I've selected five of the worst things you can plant in front of your house. Some are ugly; some are monstrous; some get bugs and disease; and some manage to do all of these things.

Undoubtedly, some of you have these plants in front of your house and will shortly be greatly offended. That's OK. Feel free to make disparaging remarks about my worthless, parasitic cat. He won't know. He can't read (though he does watch TV). Kinda like Rick Sanchez on CNN.

Awfulest of the Awful -- Golden Euonymus

GE

 

If you plant this in front of your house, you probably gave your girlfriend a pop-top for an engagement ring. I used to call golden euonymus a "gas station plant," until gas stations cleaned up their act and substituted plastic palms. Plants like this do nothing for the housing market. They are a sign that says, "For Sale by People with Absolutely No Taste."

So what's wrong with golden euonymus (Euonymus japonicus' Aureomarginatus')? Let me count the ways:

1. Mildew and scale eat it up.

2. The foliage often reverts to green, so you wind up with a bush that's half green and half yellow.

3. The garish foliage is about as subtle as a working girl's wardrobe. 

4. Out-to-lunch people pair it with 'Rosy Glow' barberry, a look much favored by legendary garden designer Ernest T. Bass.

 

Awful Plant #2 -- Bradford Pear 

Bradford  

Every Grumpian should have seen this one coming. I hate Bradford pear (Pyrus calleryana 'Bradford')! It's everywhere. Bragging about having one in your front yard is like bragging you have a toilet in your house. 

This is why I despise it:

1. It gets too big for the average yard -- 50 feet high and 40 feet wide. The only excuse for planting a row of them is if you're trying to block the view of a highway overpass.

2. Surface roots and dense shade makes it impossible to grow grass beneath it. Of course, if you've already blacktopped your yard, this won't be a problem.

3. Weak branching structure makes it very prone to storm damage. Photograph it when it's pretty. It won't stay that way long.

4. Its spring flowers smell like fish.

5. Although its flowers are self-sterile, they can cross-pollinate with other selections of callery pear, such as 'Aristocrat' and 'Cleveland Select.' When they do, they produce thousands of tiny pears, which give rise to thousands of thorny seedlings are are now invading the countryside.   


Awful Plant #3 -- Redtip Photinia

Redtip

Now I know what a lot of you are saying. "How can he hate such a purty plant? I love those shiny red leaves and the white flowers. What a churlish Grump!"

Here's my beef with redtip, AKAFraser photinia (Photinia x fraseri):

1. Like Bradford pear, it's planted everywhere in the South. Find me a trailer park, parking lot, or chain-link fence without one. It's about as common as clipping your toenails during the sermon.

2. It grows fast and big -- up to 15 feet tall and wide, much too big for the front of your house, unless you're hiding from the law. So you have to shear it often, which brings us to problem #3.

3. Most people grow it for the bright red new leaves that gradually turn green. The more you prune, the more red leaves you get. Trouble is, the new growth is extremely susceptible to a disfiguring disease, called Entomosporium leaf spot. Unless you spray regularly with a fungicide, the disease eventually kills the plant -- which, come to think of it, isn't so bad.

Awful Plant #4 -- Leyland Cypress

LC

Very few people who plant this monster have any idea how big it gets -- more than 70 feet tall and up to 15 feet wide. And because it can easily grow 3 feet a year, it doesn't take long to resemble a Saturn 5 rocket. Still, people love planting this thing on the corner of the house. The only house big enough for this is Biltmore.

In recent years, Leyland cypress (x Cupressus leylandii) has come under widespread attack by a potentially fatal fungus, seridium canker, which often causes trees to gradually die from the top down.Drought stress  favors development of this disease.

Awful Plant # 5 -- Privet

Privet  

I know a guy named Dr. Dirt who calls these shrubs "privy plants." He doesn't know how right he is. I'll admit that some of the broadleaf species, such as waxleaf privet (Ligustrum lucidum) and Japanese privet (L. japonicum) have some use in the landscape as limbed-up trees, but the small-leaf hedging types, such as California privet(L. ovalifolium) and Chinese privet (L. sinense) are absolute garbage that belong in a privy.  

Many people refer to privet by its botanical name, Ligustrum. A more accurate name is "Disgustum." How come?

1. In spring, privet produces white flowers, whose sickeningly sweet odor reminds me of the deadly dikironium cloud creature on "Star Trek."  To be fair, the cloud killed people by robbing their blood of iron. Privet flowers just cause allergies.

2. The flowers give rise to hundreds of blue-black berries relished by birds, who spread them all over the universe. As a result, privets are incredibly invasive and weedy. Plus, they grow really fast and need trimming about every two minutes or they'll swallow your house and dog. 

Now here's the weird thing. Of all the variegated plants in the world, I think variegated Chinese privet (show above) is one of the better-looking. In fact, it's perfect for next to your privy. But if I could snap my fingers and make all the privet in the world disappear, I would. I'd do the same for spammers.  

Comments

I'm with you on all of them. But despite the problems the fast growing Leyland would make a a good temporary screen as long as you could be comfortable saying goodbye to it in a few years. Although who in their right mind would plant it on a corner...oops I answered my own question! ;)

Posted by:Dave | May 15, 2009 at 12:18 PM

I am glad to say I have not sinned with these plants although I can see all of them in my various neighbors yards.

Posted by:Drew | May 15, 2009 at 12:29 PM

What 5 should everyone have? How about Live Oak, Podacarpus, Azalea, Gardenia, and Holly.

Posted by:Drew | May 15, 2009 at 12:37 PM

Oops...3 out of 5. Had you added the coveted mimosa I would have scored another. Fortunately, I can say that I learn by my mistakes...most of the time. Last fall, while attending Open Days in Raleigh, NC I stopped by Plant Delights and walked away with a Bald Cypress. What was I thinking? Why does Avent allow venders on his place to sell such things to people like me who fall in love with foliage and can't resist? For the time being I have the very small (about 15") Bald Cypress in a decorative pot.

Posted by:Vikki | May 15, 2009 at 12:58 PM

Our landscaper planted quite a few of the variegated ligustrum. We are constantly cutting them back to prevent the blooms and berries. I'd love to rip them out, but it's an expensive endeavor to rip them out and buy replacements. Don't have the others on your "awful" and unlawful list.

Cameron

Posted by:Cameron (Defining Your Home Garden) | May 15, 2009 at 02:59 PM

Ha! Steve, I'm still laughing. You have no fear!

I'm guilty of the variegated privet, which I still think is purty, esp pruned up like a small tree. I'm with you on the others. My neighbor's horrible hedge of redtip photinia that divides our yards offends me daily. I'm saving up for a fence to put up on my side to hide as much of that Christmas-y hedge as I can.

Posted by:Pam/Digging | May 15, 2009 at 06:59 PM

I couldn't agree with you more! We have the same issues here in the Sacramento area. I would add Liquid Amber, plum trees,and mimosa. The ONLY good mimosa is the one one drinks with breakfast!

Posted by:cheryl | May 15, 2009 at 07:36 PM

I couldn't agree with you more! We have the same issues here in the Sacramento area. I would add Liquid Amber, plum trees,and mimosa. The ONLY good mimosa is the one one drinks with breakfast!

Posted by:cheryl | May 15, 2009 at 07:36 PM

Grump you have named most of the plants found at nurseries in the south.I must agree they are bad.Euonymus will grow where nothing else in the world will grow. Had those on my bank out front but they succumbed to the tiller used by the nursery.They were tough little plants but are not missed. Now if we could just get rid of bradford pears!!!!Wouldnt have them in my yard.

Posted by:Jean | May 16, 2009 at 03:26 AM

You've nailed it. To your list I would add nandina as well - those ugly 'flamingo plants' are everywhere. I'm sad to say we have a golden euonymus on the corner of our house, just outside our bedroom. It's half-green, inundated with scale, and filled with chattering sparrows from dawn to dusk. It'll take a backhoe to dig the nasty old thing out. Soon!

Posted by:Caroline Homer | May 16, 2009 at 05:25 AM

You've nailed it. To your list I would add nandina as well - those ugly 'flamingo plants' are everywhere. I'm sad to say we have a golden euonymus on the corner of our house, just outside our bedroom. It's half-green, inundated with scale, and filled with chattering sparrows from dawn to dusk. It'll take a backhoe to dig the nasty old thing out. Soon!

Posted by:Caroline Homer | May 16, 2009 at 05:25 AM

You've nailed it. To your list I would add nandina as well - those ugly 'flamingo plants' are everywhere. I'm sad to say we have a golden euonymus on the corner of our house, just outside our bedroom. It's half-green, inundated with scale, and filled with chattering sparrows from dawn to dusk. It'll take a backhoe to dig the nasty old thing out. Soon!

Posted by:Caroline Homer | May 16, 2009 at 05:26 AM

I don't have any bradford pears, at least.

Posted by:Tom (7th Street Cottage) | May 16, 2009 at 04:43 PM

In interest of full disclosure, the Grump does have a row of Leyland cypress in his back yard to screen our porch from the neighbors. However, he prunes them to 15 feet every spring to keep them from getting too big.

Cheryl, I agree with you about the mimosa! Nobody really plants them here. They just come up. The nursery people tried to foist off on us that bronze-leaf mimosa a couple of years ago, but I'm not buying. A bronze weed is still a weed!

Vikki, Tony is quite up front that design is not a priority in his garden and he wants everybody to plant as many different things as possible. If you have room, don't give up on the bald cypress. Plant it where it can get big. It's one of my favorite trees. You just need the right spot.

Posted by:Grumpy Gardener | May 17, 2009 at 04:58 AM

Amen X 5.

Posted by:karenleigh | May 17, 2009 at 07:36 PM

Right on, bro. Right on. I did not know that one would purposely purchase or plant a mimosa!!!!!! Those things are harder to kill than privet. The roots will sprout shoots for YEARS even if you cut the tree down. At least you can pull privet up by the roots, in most cases.

Posted by:pc | May 17, 2009 at 08:15 PM

Wow, Grumpy -- you have such influence! My husband, at this very moment, is out digging up ALL of our variegated ligustrum! He already has 4 out of the ground!

Cameron

Posted by:Cameron (Defining Your Home Garden) | May 18, 2009 at 06:06 AM

Bradford Pear has a stink that has literally nauseated me on more than one occasion.

That any Supreme Being would claim to have intelligently designed such a thing, is beyond plausibility.

It's worse than fish.

More like the dumpster.

Behind the seafood market.

Which is where a Bradford Pear belongs.

Speaking of treestink, over the weekend, I visited my brother, who has a fig tree on his balcony, and as the day grew warmer, the stink from that thing was unbearable.

It had an olfactory cocktail of mold and armpit.

I went out there at noon, and suddenly, all the iron was removed from my body.


Just pure evil.


ugh.

Posted by:mondo | May 18, 2009 at 06:58 AM

Here in Houston I smile everytime I see a Chinese loropetalum plant or "fringe flower" in the front of a flowerbed. It'll stay nice 'n' small for a few years. Then POW! 10 ft. high & 10 ft. wide. Or bigger, now that we have no winters. I understand there's a new one just out on the market that stays small (or so they say). Haven't seen it tho. Anyone with specific "don't plant" warnings for Houston gardeners, I'd love to also pass those along on my blog: http://blogs.chron.com/lazygardener

Posted by:lazygardener | May 18, 2009 at 10:46 AM

That is some photo of the Leyland! I have a hedge of Leyland and love it. So far so good, do fungus or bag worms. It also suffers from a weak root system. After a storm I had to tie it to the neighbors chain link fence. But they perked right up.

Ligustrum's bite, varigated or otherwise. Cheap and available, they are put in by droves. I have a solid green, huge hedge - no - I have a grossly obscene wall of them on my neighbors north property line. It's their hedge, but I have a higher regard for tidiness. As such, I tend to trim 3 times to their every one. Ugh.

Posted by:Helen Yoest @ Gardening With Confidence | May 18, 2009 at 04:04 PM

P.S. you made the photo of the Redtip way too pretty. The photo makes we want one. Lucky for me, I am not so easy as that. Ok well, that's not true. Lucky for me, I'm familiar with that narly, overgrown, ligustrum-like grossly obscene bush with temping red tips.

I've never grown a Bradford pear, can't smell the bad and think they are pretty the week they bloom. But with so many great plants to choose from, why would anyone do so?

Posted by:Helen Yoest @ Gardening With Confidence | May 18, 2009 at 04:10 PM

Do you live close to me, lol. My neighbor hood is covered in all of these. NOT us. We ripped out the cyprus when we moved in and I wish I could rip out the bradford pear's in out neighbors yard. They are pushing our fence over and he doesn't care. I think I have another one to add to your list, black locust tree. These things are inpossible to kill even after it is cut down. They spring up from the roots and the thorns tear you up!

Posted by:Frankie | May 19, 2009 at 06:40 AM

Thanks for the comments everybody.

Mondo,
Your opinion of Bradford pear so closely matches my own that we could be related!

Helen,
Sorry about the pretty picture of redtip. I promise I won't do it again.

Lazy,
Agree with you about loropetalums. There are a zillion different kinds and they all look alike. I know someone who calls them "poor man's azaleas."

Cameron,
Your husband's actions regarding privet I regard as heroic.

Frankie,
The English love black locust. It's the one invasive plant we palmed off on them to get even for everything they sent us.

Posted by:Grumpy Gardener | May 19, 2009 at 12:02 PM

Yes, he's heroic... we're completely redesigning that section of the garden and he's going plant shopping with me tomorrow! :-)

And... we're adding a bench by the waterfall so he can play guitar there (as armchairs don't work with guitars). Pulling the privet gave us the extra space. Planting containers and vertical instead.

Cameron

Posted by:Cameron (Defining Your Home Garden) | May 19, 2009 at 04:37 PM

Oh, jeez... I've gotta place an emergency call to our landscaper. My husband loves to stroll around with his bagpipes. The David Austins have got to go (as thorns don't work with kilts).

Posted by:chathamcorabbit | May 19, 2009 at 07:42 PM

I sure wouldn't want to be there on a windy day.

Posted by:Grumpy Gardener | May 20, 2009 at 04:31 AM

Maybe the wind blowing his kilt is why hes' heroic!

Posted by:Drew | May 20, 2009 at 09:17 AM

How about it, Rabbit? When the wind's up, does he remind you of Braveheart?

Posted by:Grumpy Gardener | May 20, 2009 at 01:14 PM

I was just with a client this morning -- suggesting to remove the (brand new installed by the builder) golden euonymus in front of her home. She didn't object too much, thankfully, but I am forwarding this link to her now - just in case when I left she started to re-think.

Posted by:rochelle | May 20, 2009 at 03:41 PM

Out of respect for Rochelle and her client, I feel compelled to submit the following response: I have not been sufficiently briefed on the subject of Braveheart's physical attributes to answer this question in absolute terms. (You may wish to thank Rochelle and her client when you get the chance...)

Posted by:chathamcorabbit | May 20, 2009 at 08:32 PM

YOU COMPLETE ME...to coin a movie phrase. Just the mere mention of the Braford Pear on your list is vindication for all the times I've pleaded with friends to not plant that wretched weed. Between it and the honey locust, they're the only two trees landscape designers think to plant. Have they not heard of Stewartia, Halesia, Chionanthus, Lagerstroemia, Oxydendrum, Chitalpa, Amelanchier and gingko?

And don't get me started on the Leyland cypress, though your photo is the prettiest I've ever seen. (Oh that's right because they're usually brown,dying and diseased.)

Posted by:tom | tall clover farm | May 21, 2009 at 09:46 AM

To answer your question, Tom: "Have they not heard of Stewartia, Halesia, Chionanthus, Lagerstroemia, Oxydendrum, Chitalpa, Amelanchier, and Ginkgo?"

NO.

Posted by:Grumpy Gardener | May 21, 2009 at 09:51 AM

BEING SUED by a PRIVET LOVER!

My neighbor planted 750 ft. of Privet (Japanese and Chinese), 3 ft. from my property line and across two county waterways in 2002. In 2009 I finally misted it only on my side because he will not maintain it. The Privet is now 12 ft. thick and 14 ft. high and aggressively invading me.

I live in Somerville, TN. and really, really need help with this. Is there anyone out there that can legally support me in making him maintain his Privet?

I did not mean to abuse your site, I'm just desperate!

Thank you,
Michael

Posted by:Michael Soenksen | June 03, 2009 at 11:53 AM

Michael, I'm not a lawyer and I don't play one on TV, but you have my sympathy. Privet ought to be banned as noxious weeds. But I don't know the law there in TN. Can anyone help him out? What options does he have besides a couple of napalm strikes?

Posted by:Grumpy Gardener | June 03, 2009 at 12:01 PM

I'm so depressed. I just replaced a Bradford Pear that the light utility truck "accidentally" ran over and killed. How was I to know everyone hated it?

I sense a conspiracy.

Posted by:Bearsmom | June 04, 2009 at 07:36 AM

It's just with some people, you can't be subtle. If you have a redtip or privet in your yard, a word to the wise....

Posted by:Grumpy Gardener | June 05, 2009 at 06:01 AM

This is funny. Although, I do not agree with the euonymous. I had that as a foundation planting and it performed beautifully. I think the gold and green is very pretty as well. Didn't get out of hand and look unhealthy. Now that redtip photinia is something else.

Posted by:tonya | July 29, 2009 at 01:12 PM
Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In


 

Search This Blog
Advertisement